Private equity secondaries are a growing trend in the world of finance.
In simple terms, private equity secondaries refer to the buying and selling of pre-existing investor commitments to private-equity and other alternative investment funds.
They provide liquidity to investors in an otherwise illiquid market, and they have become an essential component in oiling the wheels of the private equity asset class.
Understanding private equity secondaries can be challenging, but it is essential for investors who want to diversify their portfolio and generate potential income in volatile markets.
There are different types of private equity secondaries, including traditional secondaries, direct secondaries, and GP-led secondaries.
Each type of secondary transaction has its own unique characteristics and risks that investors need to consider before investing.
The private equity secondary market has evolved and grown considerably over the past two decades, and it is now a mature and sophisticated market.
Secondary Funds Guide
However, investing in private equity secondaries is not without risks, and investors need to be aware of the regulatory landscape, market conditions, and trends that can impact their investments.
In this article, we will explore the different types of private equity secondaries, the role of different stakeholders, investment strategies in the secondary market, valuation and pricing, liquidity, regulatory landscape, market conditions and trends, risks and rewards, the role of major players, and the future of private equity secondaries.
Secondary Funds Guide
Secondary Funds – Private Equity Secondaries: An Overview of the Market
Key Takeaways
- Private equity secondaries refer to the buying and selling of pre-existing investor commitments to private-equity and other alternative investment funds, providing liquidity to investors in an otherwise illiquid market.
- There are different types of private equity secondaries, including traditional secondaries, direct secondaries, and GP-led secondaries, each with its own unique characteristics and risks.
- Investing in private equity secondaries is not without risks, and investors need to be aware of the regulatory landscape, market conditions, and trends that can impact their investments.
Understanding Private Equity Secondaries
Private equity secondaries are a type of alternative investment that involves buying and selling existing private equity investments.
These investments are typically made in private companies that are not publicly traded. Private equity secondaries can offer investors access to a wide range of private market opportunities, including venture capital, buyouts, and real estate.
Secondary Funds Guide
Investors in private equity secondaries are typically looking to diversify their portfolios and gain exposure to private market investments.
They may also be looking to take advantage of the potential for higher returns that private equity investments can offer.
Private equity secondaries can be a way for investors to gain exposure to private market investments without having to commit large amounts of capital to individual deals.
Private equity secondaries can be structured in a variety of ways, including direct purchases of individual investments or portfolios of investments.
They can also be structured as funds, allowing investors to gain exposure to a diversified portfolio of private equity investments.
One of the key benefits of private equity secondaries is the potential for higher returns compared to traditional investments in public markets.
Secondary Funds Guide
Private equity investments can offer higher returns due to their illiquidity and the potential for value creation through operational improvements and strategic initiatives.
However, private equity secondaries also come with risks.
These investments are often illiquid, meaning that investors may not be able to easily sell their investments if needed.
Additionally, private equity investments can be volatile and subject to market fluctuations.
Overall, private equity secondaries can be a valuable addition to a diversified investment portfolio.
However, investors should carefully consider the risks and potential rewards before investing in these types of alternative investments.
Types of Private Equity Secondaries
Private equity secondaries are transactions in which investors buy and sell pre-existing commitments to private equity funds.
Secondary Funds Guide
These transactions can be structured in a number of different ways based on the needs of the stakeholders involved.
In this section, we will discuss the three main types of private equity secondaries.
GP-Led Secondaries
GP-led secondaries refer to transactions in which the general partner of a private equity fund sells a portfolio of assets to a new fund managed by the same general partner.
These transactions are typically used to provide liquidity to the limited partners of the original fund, while also allowing the general partner to retain control of the underlying assets.
Secondary Funds Guide
GP-led secondaries can be further divided into two categories: single-asset and multi-asset. Single-asset transactions involve the sale of a single portfolio company, while multi-asset transactions involve the sale of a portfolio of companies.
LP-Led Secondaries
LP-led secondaries refer to transactions in which limited partners in a private equity fund sell their interests to a new group of investors.
This type of transaction is typically used to provide liquidity to limited partners who wish to exit their investments before the end of the fund’s life.
Secondary Funds Guide
LP-led secondaries can be further divided into two categories: traditional and structured.
Traditional transactions involve the sale of limited partnership interests in a private equity fund, while structured transactions involve the creation of a new vehicle to hold the assets of the original fund.
Direct Secondaries
Direct secondaries refer to transactions in which an investor purchases a portfolio of assets directly from the original owner.
This type of transaction is typically used to provide liquidity to the seller, while also allowing the buyer to acquire a portfolio of assets without having to commit to a new fund.
Direct secondaries can be further divided into two categories: single-asset and multi-asset. Single-asset transactions involve the sale of a single portfolio company, while multi-asset transactions involve the sale of a portfolio of companies.
Secondary Funds Guide
Overall, private equity secondaries provide investors with a way to gain exposure to private equity assets without having to commit to a new fund.
Whether through GP-led, LP-led, or direct secondaries, investors can gain access to a wide range of private equity assets and achieve their investment objectives.
Role of Different Stakeholders
Private equity secondaries involve various stakeholders, including general partners, limited partners, buyers, and sellers. Each stakeholder plays a unique role in the secondaries market.
General Partners
General partners (GPs) are responsible for managing the private equity fund and making investment decisions.
They are also responsible for the day-to-day operations of the fund. In the secondaries market, GPs may sell their fund interests to other investors to raise capital or to manage their portfolio.
Secondary Funds Guide
GPs may also purchase fund interests from other GPs to gain exposure to new investments or to increase their position in a particular fund.
Limited Partners
Limited partners (LPs) are investors in private equity funds.
They provide the capital that GPs use to make investments.
In the secondaries market, LPs may sell their fund interests to other investors to realize a return on their investment or to reduce their exposure to a particular fund.
LPs may also purchase fund interests from other LPs or GPs to gain exposure to new investments or to increase their position in a particular fund.
Buyers and Sellers
Buyers and sellers are the investors in the secondaries market.
Buyers may purchase fund interests from LPs or GPs to gain exposure to new investments or to increase their position in a particular fund.
Sellers may sell their fund interests to realize a return on their investment or to reduce their exposure to a particular fund.
Secondary Funds Guide
Buyers and sellers in the secondaries market may include institutional investors, such as pension funds, endowments, and sovereign wealth funds, as well as high net worth individuals and family offices.
The secondaries market provides liquidity to investors who may otherwise be locked into their investments for years.
In conclusion, each stakeholder in the private equity secondaries market plays a unique role in the buying and selling of fund interests.
While GPs and LPs are responsible for managing and investing in the funds, buyers and sellers provide liquidity to the market.
The secondaries market provides opportunities for investors to gain exposure to new investments, realize a return on their investment, or reduce their exposure to a particular fund.
Investment Strategies in Secondaries Market
Investors in private equity secondaries market use various strategies to achieve their investment objectives.
These strategies range from passive to active and depend on the investor’s risk appetite, investment horizon, and portfolio diversification goals.
One common strategy is to invest in a diversified portfolio of secondaries funds that provide exposure to a range of private equity assets.
This approach allows investors to benefit from the return potential of private equity without taking on excessive risk.
A diversified portfolio of secondaries funds can also provide investors with access to a range of geographies, sectors, and vintage years.
Another strategy is to invest in a targeted portfolio of secondaries funds that focus on specific sectors, geographies, or vintage years.
This approach allows investors to take advantage of their expertise and knowledge of a particular sector or geography. However, this strategy may be riskier than investing in a diversified portfolio of secondaries funds.
Secondary Funds Guide
Investors can also use secondaries investments to rebalance their private equity portfolios.
For example, an investor may sell a holding in a private equity fund that has performed well and use the proceeds to invest in a secondaries fund that provides exposure to a different sector or geography.
This approach can help investors to maintain a balanced and diversified private equity portfolio.
Finally, investors can use secondaries investments to manage their exposure to private equity.
For example, an investor may sell a holding in a private equity fund that has become too large relative to their overall portfolio.
Secondary Funds Guide
This approach can help investors to manage their risk and maintain a well-diversified portfolio.
Overall, investors in private equity secondaries market use a range of strategies to achieve their investment objectives.
These strategies can be passive or active, diversified or targeted, and can be used to manage risk, rebalance portfolios, or achieve portfolio diversification goals.
Valuation and Pricing
Valuation and pricing are crucial components of private equity secondaries.
The pricing of secondaries is based on the reported valuations that private equity funds publish, typically on a quarterly basis, and is expressed as a percentage of the reported Net Asset Value (NAV) (CAIA).
Private equity secondaries have traditionally priced between a discount or a premium to NAV within an average range of 90 to 105, where 100 is par (Private Equity Wire).
However, given that NAVs are typically updated quarterly, this method of secondary pricing usually lags movements in the public market by a number of months (Private Equity Wire).
Pricing dynamics in private equity secondaries are complex and influenced by a variety of factors.
The coming of age of private equity secondaries has led to a more sophisticated market with a wider range of pricing dynamics (WTW).
Secondary Funds Guide
For example, factors such as the quality of the underlying assets, the liquidity of the market, and the demand for the assets can all impact pricing dynamics.
Valuation is the process of determining the worth of an asset or company. In private equity secondaries, valuation is based on the reported NAV of the underlying private equity fund.
However, valuing private equity assets can be challenging due to the illiquid nature of the market and the lack of transparency in the underlying portfolio companies.
As a result, valuations may be subject to a degree of uncertainty and can vary depending on the methodology used (WTW).
Secondary Funds Guide
In conclusion, valuation and pricing are critical components of private equity secondaries.
The pricing of secondaries is based on the reported NAV of the underlying private equity fund, but pricing dynamics are complex and influenced by a variety of factors.
Valuation can be challenging due to the illiquid nature of the market and the lack of transparency in the underlying portfolio companies.
Liquidity and the Secondary Market
The secondary market for private equity offers an opportunity for investors to buy and sell shares in private companies.
This market provides liquidity to investors who may otherwise be locked into illiquid investments.
Liquidity is important for investors who may need to access their capital quickly, and the secondary market can provide a source of liquidity for those who need it.
The secondary market is also important for private companies and their employees.
Many private companies offer stock options to their employees as a way to incentivize them to work hard and help the company grow.
However, these stock options can be illiquid, and employees may not be able to access the value of their shares until the company goes public or is acquired.
The secondary market offers a way for employees to sell their shares and access the value of their equity before an exit event occurs.
Secondary Funds Guide
This can be especially important for employees who need to raise capital for personal reasons, such as buying a house or paying for their children’s education.
The secondary market can also be a valuable tool for investors who need to rebalance their portfolios.
Private equity investments can be illiquid and difficult to value, which can make it challenging to manage a portfolio.
The secondary market offers a way for investors to sell their positions and reallocate capital to other investments.
Overall, the secondary market for private equity provides liquidity to investors and employees who may otherwise be locked into illiquid investments.
It can also be a valuable tool for portfolio management and rebalancing.
Regulatory Landscape
Private equity secondaries are subject to various regulatory requirements and laws.
The regulatory landscape for private equity secondaries is constantly evolving, and it is important for market participants to stay up to date with the latest developments to ensure compliance.
Regulatory bodies such as the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the US play a crucial role in shaping the regulatory landscape for private equity secondaries.
The FCA has implemented various rules and regulations to ensure that private equity firms conduct their business in a fair and transparent manner. Similarly, the SEC has implemented various rules and regulations to ensure that private equity firms comply with securities laws and regulations.
Secondary Funds Guide
In addition to regulatory bodies, there are also various laws and regulations that impact private equity secondaries.
For example, the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD) in the EU imposes various requirements on alternative investment fund managers, including private equity firms.
The AIFMD requires private equity firms to be authorized and regulated by the relevant regulatory body in their jurisdiction, and to comply with various reporting and disclosure requirements.
Another important regulatory development in the private equity secondary market is the increasing focus on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues.
Private equity firms are increasingly being held accountable for the impact of their investments on the environment and society.
Secondary Funds Guide
As a result, private equity firms are implementing various ESG policies and practices to ensure that their investments are sustainable and socially responsible.
In summary, the regulatory landscape for private equity secondaries is complex and constantly evolving.
Private equity firms must stay up to date with the latest developments to ensure compliance with various laws and regulations. Regulatory bodies, laws and regulations, and ESG issues all play a crucial role in shaping the regulatory landscape for private equity secondaries.
Market Conditions and Trends
The private equity secondary market has seen significant growth in recent years.
According to Barclays Private Bank, secondary deal volume grew from $26 billion in 2013 to a record $134 billion in 2021, which equates to a compound rate of 23% per year.
Volumes in 2022 remained high at $108 billion, the second biggest year on record, but slowed during the second half amid public market volatility and lower market pricing.
Secondary Funds Guide
Despite the slowdown in the second half of 2022, the GP-led secondary market reached $68 billion globally in 2021, about half of the overall secondaries market, and an almost 100% increase from the year prior, according to Morgan Stanley.
About 44% of GP-led secondaries were invested in single-asset continuation funds in 2021, as investors gravitated toward highly concentrated exposure to managers and portfolios.
The market for private-equity secondaries has evolved and grown considerably over the past two decades, providing liquidity to investors in an otherwise illiquid market, according to abrdn.
Secondaries have become an essential component in oiling the wheels of the private equity (PE) asset class.
Market downturns have historically provided opportunities for secondary buyers to acquire assets at discounted prices.
Secondary Funds Guide
However, the market has become more competitive in recent years, with more players entering the market and driving up prices.
As a result, buyers are increasingly looking for alternative ways to gain exposure to the asset class, such as through co-investment opportunities or direct investments in private equity funds.
In terms of deal activity, the market has seen a shift towards larger deals in recent years.
This trend is expected to continue as more institutional investors enter the market and seek larger deals to deploy capital.
Secondary Funds Guide
Additionally, GP-led secondaries are expected to continue to grow in popularity as more managers look to provide liquidity to their investors and extend the life of their funds.
Overall, the private equity secondary market is expected to continue to grow and evolve in the coming years, as investors seek new ways to gain exposure to the asset class and managers look for ways to provide liquidity to their investors.
Risks and Rewards
Private equity secondaries offer investors a unique opportunity to invest in a diversified portfolio of private equity assets.
However, like any investment, there are risks and rewards to consider.
Risks
One of the biggest risks associated with private equity secondaries is the J-curve effect.
This occurs when the initial investments made by the fund do not generate returns for several years.
During this time, the fund is still incurring expenses, which can result in negative returns. As a result, investors may experience a temporary loss of capital.
Secondary Funds Guide
Another risk to consider is the potential for a lack of liquidity.
Private equity investments are typically illiquid, meaning that investors may not be able to sell their shares quickly or at a fair price.
This lack of liquidity can make it difficult for investors to exit their positions if they need to raise cash quickly.
Rewards
Despite the risks, private equity secondaries can offer investors attractive risk-adjusted returns. Private equity investments typically offer higher returns than public market investments, and secondaries can provide additional diversification benefits.
Investing in private equity secondaries can also help mitigate the J-curve effect.
Secondary Funds Guide
By investing in a fund that has already been established, investors can benefit from the early years of the fund’s returns, which can offset the negative returns experienced during the initial investment period.
Overall, private equity secondaries can be a valuable addition to an investor’s portfolio. However, it is important to carefully consider the risks and rewards before making an investment.
Role of Major Players
Private equity secondaries market is dominated by a few big players, who have the expertise, resources, and network to execute complex transactions.
Secondary Funds Guide
In this section, we will discuss the role of two major players in the market: Morgan Stanley and Greenhill.
Morgan Stanley
Morgan Stanley is one of the largest investment banks in the world, with a strong presence in private equity secondaries market.
The bank offers a range of services to its clients, including advisory, fundraising, and direct investment.
Morgan Stanley has a dedicated team of professionals who specialize in secondaries, and they have a deep understanding of the market dynamics, trends, and opportunities.
Secondary Funds Guide
Morgan Stanley has been involved in some of the largest and most complex secondaries transactions in recent years, and they have a track record of delivering value to their clients.
The bank has a global network of investors, which allows them to source deals from around the world. They also have access to a large pool of capital, which they can use to support their clients’ transactions.
Greenhill
Greenhill is a leading independent investment bank, which provides advisory services to clients in various sectors, including private equity secondaries.
The bank has a team of experienced professionals who have worked on some of the most significant secondaries transactions in recent years. Greenhill offers a range of services to its clients, including strategic advice, valuation, and execution.
Greenhill has a strong reputation in the market, and they are known for their expertise, integrity, and discretion.
Secondary Funds Guide
The bank has a global network of investors, which allows them to source deals from around the world. They also have a deep understanding of the market dynamics, which enables them to provide valuable insights and advice to their clients.
In conclusion, Morgan Stanley and Greenhill are two major players in the private equity secondaries market, who have the expertise, resources, and network to execute complex transactions.
They have a deep understanding of the market dynamics, trends, and opportunities, and they are known for their expertise, integrity, and discretion.
Future of Private Equity Secondaries
The private equity secondary market is expected to continue its growth trajectory in the coming years, driven by a combination of factors such as future capital calls, over-allocation, and technology.
One key driver of growth is the increasing demand for liquidity from limited partners (LPs).
As more LPs seek to rebalance their portfolios and generate cash to meet future capital calls, they are turning to the secondary market as a source of liquidity.
This trend is expected to continue in the future, with LP demand for liquidity driving record levels of deal flow in the private equity secondary market.
Another factor driving growth in the secondary market is over-allocation.
As LPs continue to allocate more capital to private equity, they are becoming increasingly over-allocated to the asset class.
Secondary Funds Guide
This over-allocation is leading to a need for LPs to sell their existing positions in order to rebalance their portfolios. This trend is expected to continue in the future, driving demand for secondary market transactions.
Technology is also expected to play a significant role in the future of the private equity secondary market.
Secondary Funds Guide
As technology continues to evolve, it is enabling greater efficiency and transparency in the secondary market.
For example, the use of blockchain technology is expected to streamline the process of transferring ownership of private equity assets, making it easier for LPs to sell their positions and for buyers to acquire them.
Overall, the future of the private equity secondary market looks bright, with continued growth expected in the coming years.
As LPs seek liquidity, rebalance their portfolios, and take advantage of technological advancements, the secondary market is likely to remain a key component of the private equity asset class.
Secondary funds – Frequently Asked Questions
What are the different types of private equity secondary transactions?
Private equity secondaries can be categorised into two types: limited partner (LP) transactions and general partner (GP) transactions.
LP transactions involve the sale of all fund investments to a secondary market fund or to another investor. In contrast, GP transactions are typically portfolio company transfers to a new fund vehicle.
What are the key factors to consider when investing in private equity secondaries?
When investing in private equity secondaries, investors should consider several factors such as the fund’s track record, the quality of the underlying portfolio companies, the fund’s investment strategy, and the experience of the fund manager.
Additionally, investors should consider the fund’s fee structure, liquidity terms, and the potential risks associated with the investment.
How do private equity secondary transactions impact the primary market?
Private equity secondary transactions can have a significant impact on the primary market.
Secondary Funds Guide
By providing liquidity to investors, secondary transactions allow investors to sell their positions in private equity funds and reinvest the proceeds in other assets.
This can lead to increased demand for primary fund investments, which can drive up prices and reduce returns.
What are the risks associated with investing in private equity secondaries?
Investing in private equity secondaries can be risky. Some of the key risks include the illiquidity of the investment, the potential for limited information about the underlying portfolio companies, and the possibility of underperformance due to changes in market conditions or the fund manager’s investment strategy.
What are the benefits of investing in private equity secondaries?
Investing in private equity secondaries can provide investors with several benefits such as access to a diversified portfolio of private equity investments, potential for higher returns than traditional asset classes, and the ability to generate cash flow from secondary transactions.
Secondary Funds Guide
Additionally, secondary transactions can provide investors with the opportunity to invest in funds that are closed to new investors.
What are the current trends in the private equity secondary market?
The private equity secondary market has experienced significant growth in recent years.
Some of the current trends in the market include increased demand for secondary transactions, a larger number of buyers and sellers, and a shift towards larger transactions.
Additionally, there has been a trend towards greater transparency in the market, with more information being made available to investors.
Secondary Funds Guide
